My Three Passions by Bertrand Russell

-

My Three Passions by Bertrand Russell



From the context of the passage, guess the meaning of the words and phrases in the box

wayward course ocean of anguish

 verge of despair

 

mystic miniature unfathomable abyss

 

apprehend reverberate

 

 

Ans: wayward course: An unpredictable or erratic path in life.

ocean of anguish: A vast, overwhelming amount of emotional pain or suffering.

verge of despair: The point just before completely losing hope.

mystic miniature: A small-scale representation of something spiritual or profoundly meaningful.

unfathomable abyss: An immeasurably deep or incomprehensible void. In the context, it refers to the terrifying emptiness or meaninglessness one might perceive in the universe without love.

apprehend: To understand or grasp (an idea).

reverberate: To echo or resound repeatedly.

Understanding The Text

1.      Why does Russell call the three passions 'simple'?

Ans: Russell calls the three passions 'simple' because they are fundamental and straightforward human desires. Despite their profound impact on his life, these passions - love, knowledge, and pity for human suffering - are basic and easily understood concepts that most people can relate to.

2.      Why has he compared the three passions to great winds?

Ans: Russell compares the passions to great winds because they have powerfully influenced and directed the course of his life, much like strong winds can blow a ship in various directions. This metaphor emphasizes how these passions have been a driving force, sometimes pushing him in unpredictable ways.

3.      What, according to Russell, is the importance of love in life?

Ans: According to Russell, love is important for three main reasons:

·         It brings ecstasy and intense joy, so great that he would sacrifice much for even a few hours of it.

·         It relieves the terrible loneliness of human existence.

·         In the union of love, it provides a glimpse of a heavenly vision, similar to what saints and poets have imagined.

4.      How does Russell's definition of knowledge differ from what is commonly understood by the term? Ans: Russell's definition of knowledge is broader and more profound than the common understanding. While people often think of knowledge as factual information, Russell seeks:

·         To understand the hearts of men (human nature and psychology)

·         To know why the stars shine (scientific understanding of the universe)

·         To comprehend the mathematical principles governing reality (abstract and philosophical knowledge)

5.      Why is the quality of pity earth-bound while the other two passions are elevating?

Ans: Pity is described as earth-bound because it constantly brings Russell back to the harsh realities of human suffering on Earth. While love and knowledge allow him to experience ecstasy or pursue lofty intellectual concepts, pity grounds him in the concrete struggles and pain of humanity. It prevents him from escaping into purely abstract or joyful realms.

6.      How have the three passions contributed to the quality of Russell's life?

Ans: The three passions have contributed to Russell's life by:

·         Providing intense and meaningful experiences (especially through love)

·         Driving his intellectual pursuits and expanding his understanding of the world (through the search for knowledge)

·         Keeping him connected to humanity and aware of the world's problems (through pity)

·         Giving his life purpose and direction

·         Making his life feel worthwhile and fulfilling, despite the challenges and suffering he has encountered

Overall, these passions have made Russell's life rich and meaningful, to the extent that he would gladly live it again if given the chance.

How does Russell’s concept of love and pity tie up with King’s concepts of agape?

Russell's concept of love and pity:

  1. Love: For Russell, love is both personal and transcendent. It brings ecstasy, relieves loneliness, and offers a glimpse of something higher or divine.
  2. Pity: Russell's pity is an "unbearable pity for the suffering of mankind." It's a deep empathy that connects him to human suffering and brings him back to earth from his intellectual and emotional heights.

King's concept of agape: Agape, as described by Martin Luther King Jr., is a form of love that is:

  1. Unconditional and universal
  2. Not based on merit, but on need
  3. Active and seeks the well-being of others
  4. Extends even to one's enemies

Connections between Russell's ideas and King's agape:

  1. Universal concern: Both Russell's pity and King's agape involve a concern for all of humanity. Russell speaks of pity for "the suffering of mankind," while agape is a love extended to all, regardless of who they are.
  2. Active compassion: Russell's pity leads him to "long to alleviate the evil," even though he feels he cannot fully do so. This aligns with King's view of agape as an active force that seeks to help others.
  3. Transcendent quality: Russell sees in love a "prefiguring vision of the heaven that saints and poets have imagined." This hints at a higher, spiritual quality of love that resonates with King's concept of agape as a divine, selfless love.
  4. Grounding in human reality: Russell's pity brings him "back to earth," keeping him connected to human suffering. Similarly, King's agape is not an abstract concept but a practical force for addressing real-world injustices.
  5. Personal cost: Russell mentions that he too suffers because of his pity. This echoes King's understanding that agape love often involves personal sacrifice for the good of others.

Key differences:

  1. Scope: Russell separates love (which seems more personal) from pity (which is more universal). King's agape combines these, extending the highest form of love to all.
  2. Action: While Russell expresses a desire to help, he seems more passive or helpless in the face of suffering. King's concept of agape is inherently active and transformative.
  3. Philosophical vs. Theological: Russell's view is more philosophical and personal, while King's concept of agape is rooted in Christian theology and aimed at social change.

In conclusion, while Russell doesn't use the term agape, his combined concepts of love and pity share significant overlap with King's idea of agape love, particularly in their universal scope and deep concern for human welfare. However, King's agape is more explicitly action-oriented and grounded in a theological framework aimed at social transformation.

 

  

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Last Lesson by Alphonse Daudet

-
Image
  The Last Lesson by Alphonse Daudet Franz is scared of going to school as his French teacher M. Hamel had announced a test on participles which he had not learnt. Although, Franz wants day out of the school and enjoy beauty of nature- the bright sunshine, the birds chirping in the woods, but eventually decides to go to the school. On the way, he passes through the Town Hall and notices a huge crowd around the Notice board. He does not stop as Bulletin board served all bad news, lost battles, the drafts and orders of the commanding officers. He sees Prussian soldiers drilling but resists. On reaching the school, he notices that everything was as quiet as a Sunday morning. He is not scolded by the teacher. Franz observes that the teacher is dressed in a ceremonial uniform which he wears on prize ceremonies and inspection day only. He is surprised to the villagers occupying the last benches- old Hauser, former mayor and postmaster were also there. M. Hamel announced the notice which wa
Read more

My Mother at Sixty-Six by Kamala Das

-
Image
  My Mother at Sixty Six The poet is driving from her parents home to Cochin by car, her mother by her side—sleeping – open mouthed very pale, colourless and frail-like a dead body indicating that her end was near. The poet looks at her and feels intense pain and agony to realize that soon death will cast her mother from her. She tries to divert her mind, looks outside at the young trees and happy children bursting out of their homes in a playful mood. After the security check at the airport she looks again at her mother’s face—pale and cold. The poet has always had a very intimate and close relationship with her mother and she has always felt the fear of being separated from her mother hence it is familiar. The poet reassures her mother that they will meet again. NCERT Book Solution Page No: 91 Think it Out 1. What is the kind of pain and ache that the poet feels? OR What kind of pain does Kamala Das feel in ‘My Mother at Sixty-six’? (2017 Delhi) Answer: The childhoo
Read more

Lost Spring by Anees Jung

-
Image
  Available on Flipkart & Amazon Lost Spring by Anees Jung W       The writer Anees Jung encounters Saheb - a rag picker whose parents have left behind the life of poverty in Dhaka to earn a living in Delhi. His family like many other families of rag pickers lives in Seemapuri. They do not have any identification other than a ration card. The children do not go to school and they are excited at the prospect of finding a coin or even a ten rupee note for scrounging in the garbage. It is the only way of earning a living. The writer is pained to see Saheb-e-alam losing the spark of childhood and roaming barefoot with his friends. Later on Saheb works in a tea stall and is paid Rs. 800 per month. He sadly realizes that he is no longer a free bird and master of his own will. He is more of a bonded labourer with surrendered freedom and identity and this loss weighs heavily on his tender shoulders. The author then tells about another victim of poverty, Mukesh who wants to be a motor
Read more